public hearings and
proposed agendaS
March 9, 2010
MEMORANDUM
TO: WHOM IT MAY CONCERN
FROM: URBAN DESIGN STAFF
RE: UPCOMING URBAN DESIGN COMMISSION
MEETING AGENDA
Enclosed for your information is the agenda for the Urban Design Commission meeting. There may be items of business which are of interest to you and we welcome your attendance at the time and place shown below. Persons who have submitted a project for review by the Commission are expected to attend and will be given the opportunity to make a brief statement.
DATE: March 24, 2010
TIME: 4:00 P.M.
PLACE: Atlanta City Hall
City Council Chambers
2nd Floor
55 Trinity Ave., S.W.
For further information about our agenda, please call 404.330.6200.
AGENDA
March 10, 2010
(Reconvened March 24, 2010)
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-036) to allow renovations and alterations to existing front porch at 1074 Oak Street – Property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: Gregory Young
1595 South Gordon Street
b) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-10-037) to allow renovations at 399 Edgewood Avenue – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 5).
Applicant: Lorraine Cunanan
429 Edgewood Avenue
c) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LBS-10-040) to allow the installation of landscaping on Block 85 at 438 Memorial Drive (Oakland Cemetery) – Property is zoned Oakland Cemetery Landmark District.
Applicant: Historic Oakland Foundation
248 Oakland Avenue
d) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LBS-10-041) to allow the restoration of the church bell at 438 Memorial Drive (Oakland Cemetery) – Property is zoned Oakland Cemetery Landmark District.
Applicant: Historic Oakland Foundation
248 Oakland Avenue
e) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LBS-10-042) to allow various repairs in FEMA Section 1-8 at 438 Memorial Drive (Oakland Cemetery) – Property is zoned Oakland Cemetery Landmark District.
Applicant: Historic Oakland Foundation
248 Oakland Avenue
f) Review and Comment (RC-10-043) on a special use permit (U-10-006) for a cell tower extension at 949 Confederate Avenue – Property is zoned C-2-C/Grant Park Historic District.
Applicant: T-Mobile South
2470 Windy Hill Road, Marietta
g) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-10-044) to allow the demolition of a structure due to a threat to public health and safety at 523 Irwin Street – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 2).
Applicant: Bureau of Code Compliance- In Rem
55 Trinity Avenue, Suite 3450
h) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-045) to allow rear addition and renovations at 836 Dixie Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Adam Stillman
350 Sinclair Avenue
i) Review and Comment (RC-10-047) on the construction of a spray ground with restrooms at 211 Thornton Street (Arthur Langford Park) – Property is zoned R-4A.
Applicant: City of Atlanta- Parks Design
675 Ponce de Leon Avenue
j) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness (HD-10-048) on a variance to increase the southwest side yard setback from 4.3 ft. (required) to 12 ft. (proposed), increase the maximum height from 21 ft. (required) to 26.5 ft (proposed), increase the height of the first floor above grade from 49 in. (required) to 53 in. (proposed) and to allow different roof pitch, fenestration , front porch, ornamentation, use of dormers and front step/walkway configuration then that allowed by the compatibility rule; and (HD-10-049) to allow the construction of a single family residence at 851 Virgil Street (aka 0 Hale Street) – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Ute Banse
1077 Alta Avenue
k) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness (LD-10-050) on a variance to increase the east side yard from 2 ft. (required) to 4 ft. (proposed), increase the maximum height from 16 ft. 8 in. (required) to 22 ft. 2 in. (proposed), and to allow different fenestration, siding, front door, and roof form and pitch from 723 Mollie Street; and (LD-10-051) to allow the construction of a new single family residence at 731 Mollie Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: David Butler
212 Gibson Street
l) Review and Comment (RC-10-052) on the alterations to the façades at 200 Peachtree Street – Property is zoned SPI-1.
Applicant: Lloyd Myers
27 Covington Road, Avondale Estates
m) Review and Comment (RC-10-053) on the removal of a metal building to build an athletic field and gazebo at 4469 Stella Drive (Chastain Park) – Property is zoned R-3.
Applicant: Ed Castro Landscape
1125 Old Ellis Road, Roswell
n) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-10-054) to allow renovations on the side and rear elevations at 858 Oakdale Road – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District.
Applicant: Michael Nualla
124 S. Columbia Drive, Decatur
o) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-028) to allow the demolition of a structure due to a threat to public health and safety at 999 Sparks Street – Property is zoned R-5/Oakland City Historic District.
Applicant: Bureau of Code Compliance- In Rem
55 Trinity Avenue, Suite 3450
-Deferred from the meeting of February 24, 2010, at the Commissioner’s request.
p) Review and Comment (RC-10-033) on a special exception for a reduction in off street parking (from 26 spaces to 13 spaces) at 575 Boulevard S. E. – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Jeffrey Wilson
181 Pearl Street
-Deferred from the meeting of February 24, 2010, due to the need for an amended special exception request.
q) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (IP-09-201) to allow site work (community garden) in Freedom Park (intersection of Hurt and Euclid Avenues) – Property is zoned SPI-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Inman Park Community Garden
970 Waverly Way
-Deferred from the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 27, 2010.
-Deferred from the meeting of February 10, 2010, at the Staff’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of February 24, 2010, at the Applicant’s request.
Proposed
AGENDA
March 24, 2010
r) Review and Comment (RC-10-055) on application V-10-021 for a variance to increase the lot coverage from 55% (allowed) to 60% (proposed) at 503 Broyles Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District.
Applicant: Reed Coss
503 Broyles Street
s) Review and Comment (RC-10-057) on the collocation of antennas on an existing cell tower and a new equipment cabinet on City of Atlanta property at 326 Moreland Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Clearwire GA Atlanta 531
11390 Old Roswell Road, Alpharetta
t) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-059) to allow the demolition of a structure due to a threat to public health and safety at 654 McDonald Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Timothy Wright
8642 Prather Drive, Jonesboro
u) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-060) to allow new addition, new signage and new canopy to an existing building at 428 Boulevard S.E. – Property is zoned NC-7-C/Grant Park Historic District.
Applicant: Joel Sadler
428 Boulevard S.E.
v) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-063) to allow the replacement of existing masonite siding with hardiplank siding at 89 Spruce Street – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Clarence F. Williams, III
89 Spruce Street
w) Review and Comment (RC-10-064) on site work, addition, and alterations at 3450 Benjamin E. Mays Drive (Benjamin E. Mays High School) – Property is zoned R-3.
Applicant: M. Susanne Blam
1382 Peachtree Street
x) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-065) to allow the construction of a new single family residence and garage at 627 Robinson Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/ Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: James Cheeks
949 N. Ormewood Park Drive
y) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness (HD-10-066) on a variance to use another block as the point of comparison for the proposed project: and to increase the north sideyard setback from 1-8 feet (allowed) to 20.5 feet (proposed); and (HD-10-014) to allow rear addition, pergola and front façade renovations at 418 North Highland Avenue – Property is zoned RG-2/ Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: John William Pigott
418 North Highland Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of February 10, 2010, due to the lack of a sign posting affidavit and at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of February 24, 2010, due to the need for a variance.
5. Other Business—
6. Adjournment
Proposed
AGENDA
March 10, 2010
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-036) to allow renovations and alterations to existing front porch at 1074 Oak Street – Property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: Gregory Young
1595 South Gordon Street
b) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-10-037) to allow renovations at 399 Edgewood Avenue – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 5).
Applicant: Lorraine Cunanan
429 Edgewood Avenue
c) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LBS-10-040) to allow the installation of landscaping on Block 85 at 438 Memorial Drive (Oakland Cemetery) – Property is zoned Oakland Cemetery Landmark District.
Applicant: Historic Oakland Foundation
248 Oakland Avenue
d) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LBS-10-041) to allow the restoration of the church bell at 438 Memorial Drive (Oakland Cemetery) – Property is zoned Oakland Cemetery Landmark District.
Applicant: Historic Oakland Foundation
248 Oakland Avenue
e) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LBS-10-042) to allow various repairs in FEMA Section 1-8 at 438 Memorial Drive (Oakland Cemetery) – Property is zoned Oakland Cemetery Landmark District.
Applicant: Historic Oakland Foundation
248 Oakland Avenue
f) Review and Comment (RC-10-043) on a special use permit (U-10-006) for a cell tower extension at 949 Confederate Avenue – Property is zoned C-2-C/Grant Park Historic District.
Applicant: T-Mobile South
2470 Windy Hill Road, Marietta
g) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-10-044) to allow the demolition of a structure due to a threat to public health and safety at 523 Irwin Street – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 2).
Applicant: Bureau of Code Compliance- In Rem
55 Trinity Avenue, Suite 3450
h) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-045) to allow rear addition and renovations at 836 Dixie Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Adam Stillman
350 Sinclair Avenue
i) Review and Comment (RC-10-047) on the construction of a spray ground with restrooms at 211 Thornton Street (Arthur Langford Park) – Property is zoned R-4A.
Applicant: City of Atlanta- Parks Design
675 Ponce de Leon Avenue
j) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness (HD-10-048) on a variance to increase the southwest side yard setback from 4.3ft. (required) to 12 ft. (proposed), increase the maximum height from 21 ft. (required) to 26.5 ft. (proposed), increase the height of the first floor above grade from 49 in. (required) to 53 in. (proposed) and to allow different roof pitch, fenestration , front porch, ornamentation, use of dormers and front steps/walkway configuration then that allowed by the compatibility rule; and (HD-10-049) to allow the construction of a single family residence at 851 Virgil Street (aka 0 Hale Street) – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Ute Banse
1077 Alta Avenue
k) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness (LD-10-050) on a variance to increase the east side yard from 2 ft. (required) to 4 ft. (proposed), increase the maximum height from 16 ft. 8 in. (required) to 22 ft. 2 in. (proposed), and to allow different fenestration,siding, front door, and roof form and pitch from 723 Mollie Street; and (LD-10-051) to allow the construction of a new single family residence at 731 Mollie Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: David Butler
212 Gibson Street
l) Review and Comment (RC-10-052) on the alterations to the façades at 200 Peachtree Street – Property is zoned SPI-1.
Applicant: Lloyd Myers
27 Covington Road, Avondale Estates
m) Review and Comment (RC-10-053) on the removal of a metal building to build an athletic field and gazebo at 4469 Stella Drive (Chastain Park) – Property is zoned R-3.
Applicant: Ed Castro Landscape
1125 Old Ellis Road, Roswell
n) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-10-054) to allow renovations on the side and rear elevations at 858 Oakdale Road – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District.
Applicant: Michael Nualla
124 S. Columbia Drive, Decatur
o) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-028) to allow the demolition of a structure due to a threat to public health and safety at 999 Sparks Street – Property is zoned R-5/Oakland City Historic District.
Applicant: Bureau of Code Compliance- In Rem
55 Trinity Avenue, Suite 3450
-Deferred from the meeting of February 24, 2010, at the Commissioner’s request.
p) Review and Comment (RC-10-033) on a special exception for a reduction in off street parking (from 26 spaces to 13 spaces) at 575 Boulevard S. E. – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Jeffrey Wilson
181 Pearl Street
-Deferred from the meeting of February 24, 2010, due to the need for an amended special exception request.
q) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (IP-09-201) to allow site work (community garden) in Freedom Park (intersection of Hurt and Euclid Avenues) – Property is zoned SPI-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Inman Park Community Garden
970 Waverly Way
-Deferred from the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 27, 2010.
-Deferred from the meeting of February 10, 2010, at the Staff’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of February 24, 2010, at the Applicant’s request.
5. Other Business—
6. Adjournment
Proposed
AGENDA
February 24, 2010
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-21) to allow new signage at 487 North Highland Avenue – Property is zoned RG-2/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Sangita Dongol
487 North Highland Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
b) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-025) to allow front façade renovations at 685 Woodward Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: John E. Swiney
145 Thistlewood Lane, Fairburn
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
c) Review and Comment (RC-10-026) on the demolition of a structure at 81 Cleveland Avenue (Cleveland Avenue Elementary School) – Property is zoned R4.
Applicant: Atlanta Public School
1631 LaFrance Street
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments; strongly opposition.
d) Review and Comment (RC-10-027) on the demolition of a structure at 1965 Lewis Road (Old Dobbs Elementary School) – Property is zoned R4.
Applicant: Atlanta Public School
1631 LaFrance Street
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments; strongly opposition.
e) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-028) to allow the demolition of a structure due to a threat to public health and safety at 999 Sparks Street – Property is zoned R-5/Oakland City Historic District.
Applicant: Bureau of Code Compliance- In Rem
55 Trinity Avenue, Suite 3450
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of March 10, 2010.
f) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-10-029) for a variance to reduce the front yard setback from 11’ (required) to 4’ (proposed) and to reduce the east side yard setback from 42’ (required) to 0’ (proposed); and a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-10-030) to allow a new canopy and site work at 1200 (aka 1192) Ponce de Leon Avenue (Druid Hills United Methodist Church) – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District.
Applicant: Barbara Crum/ Allen Post
1382 Peachtree Street
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
g) Review and Comment (RC-10-031) on a new field house, canopies, and equipment storage at 2875 Northside Drive (North Atlanta High School) – Property is zoned R-3.
Applicant: Bill Polk
15 Simpson Street
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support with comments.
h) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-032) to allow window, door, and siding replacement and other renovations at 949 Mathews Street – Property is zoned R-4A/ West End Historic District.
Applicant: Bel Air Home Services
1965 Carlotte Court
Commission Voted: Approved with amended conditions.
i) Review and Comment (RC-10-033) on a special exception for a reduction in off street parking (from 26 spaces to 13 spaces) at 575 Boulevard S. E. – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Jeffrey Wilson
181 Pearl Street
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of March 10, 2010.
j) Review and Comment (RC-10-039) on a new handicap ramp located in the public right-of- way at 407 Auburn Avenue (Ebenezer Baptist Church) – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: National Park Service
450 Auburn Avenue, NE
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
k) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-122) to allow the demolition of a two-story building due to a threat to public health and safety at 227-229 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4).
Applicant: Ivan Thornton
304 Park Avenue South, New York, New York
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, due to the need for proper notice.
-Deferred from the meeting of August 12, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 27, 2010, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Denied without prejudice.
l) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-139) to allow the demolition of a building due to unreasonable economic return at 245/247 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4).
Applicant: Quencis Jones
975 Tuckawanna Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of August 27, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 27, 2010, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of April 14, 2010, at the Commissioner's request.
m) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (IP-09-201) to allow site work (community garden) in Freedom Park (intersection of Hurt and Euclid Avenues) – Property is zoned SPI-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Inman Park Community Garden
970 Waverly Way
-Deferred from the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 27, 2010.
-Deferred from the meeting of February 10, 2010, at the Staff’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of March 10, 2010, at the Applicant's request.
n) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-241) for a variance from the requirement to use asphalt shingles (required by the compatibility rule) to allow the installation of a standing seam metal roof (proposed) at 158 Elizabeth Street – Property is zoned R-5/ Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Robert Foah
158 Elizabeth Street
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of may 12, 2010, at the Applicant's request.
o) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-265) to allow a replacement structure at 1509 South Ponce de Leon Avenue – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Allen Post/ Perkins+Will
1382 Peachtree Street
-Deferred from the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Commissioner’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 27, 2010, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with amended conditions.
p) Review and Comment (RC-09-277) on the Ansley Park Traffic Improvement Revised Master Plan in the Ansley Park Neighborhood – Property is zoned R-3.
Applicant: Tunnell & Tunnell Landscape Architecture for the Ansley Park Civic Association
1123 Zondite Road, Suite1
-Deferred from the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 27, 2010, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Denied without prejudice. (5 Yeas and 1 recusal)
q) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-014) to allow rear addition, pergola and front façade renovations at 418 North Highland Avenue – Property is zoned RG-2/ Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: John William Pigott
418 North Highland Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of February 10, 2010, due to the lack of a sign posting affidavit and at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of March 24, 2010, due to the need for proper advertisement of a variance.
5. Other Business—
6. Adjournment
Proposed
AGENDA
February 10, 2010
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-10-010) to allow window replacement and roof repairs at 154 Howell Street – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 2).
Applicant: DNK Development LLC
820 Dekalb Avenue, #16
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
b) Review and Comment (RC-10-012) on the addition of nature boardwalks at 532 Lynnhaven Drive (Emma Millican Park) – Property is zoned R-4.
Applicant: Jessica Evans
1125 Old Ellis Road, Roswell
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support.
c) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-10-013) to allow rear and deck addition at 86 Bradley Street – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 2).
Applicant: Jason Ryan and Greg Pereira
86 Bradley Street
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
d) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-014) to allow rear addition, pergola and front façade renovations at 418 North Highland Avenue – Property is zoned RG-2/ Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: John William Pigott
418 North Highland Avenue
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of February 24, 2010, due to the lack of a sign posting affidavit and at the Applicant's request.
e) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-022) for a variance to increase the north sideyard setback from 23.0’ (required) to 32.5’ (proposed) and the south sideyard setback from 14’ (required) to 8.5' (proposed) at 81 Spruce Street – Property is zoned R-5/ Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Carol M. Worthman
81 Spruce Street
Commission Voted: Approved.
f) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-221) for a variance from the requirement that the compatibility rule comparison be based on the subject property’s block, a variance from the requirement that the compatibility rule comparison be based on structures of like use, and a variance to allow an increase in the front yard setback from 0’ (required) to 5’ (proposed) and (LD-09-183) to allow lot consolidation and the construction of a new single family house at 605 – 609 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District.
Applicant: Jason Parker
10 Jackson Street
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 27, 2010, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of April 28, 2010, at the Applicant's request.
g) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (IP-09-201) to allow site work (community garden) in Freedom Park (intersection of Hurt and Euclid Avenues) – Property is zoned SPI-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Inman Park Community Garden
970 Waverly Way
-Deferred from the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 27, 2010.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of February 24, 2010, at the Staff's request.
h) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-228) to allow an addition and renovations at 1251 Greenwich Street – Property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: Anna-Marie Muslar
6470 Long Island Drive, Sandy Springs
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Commissioner’s and Staff’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
i) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-261) to allow the construction of a new single family residence at 807 Lynwood Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1) / Beltline Overlay.
Applicant: Robert Gunnison, Stoney River Construction
P. O. Box 2507, Decatur
-Deferred from the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Commissioner’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
j) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-272) for a variance to allow metal or non-asphalt shingles when asphalt shingles would otherwise be required and an Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-273) to allow revisions to plans at 182 Degress Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Frank Neely, Frank G. Neely Design Inc.
1447 Peachtree Street, Suite 844
-Deferred from the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: (HD-09-272) Approved (HD-09-273) Approved with condition.
k) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness (HD-10-018) for a variance to increase the west sideyard setback 2.5’-5.0’ (required) to 12.0’ (proposed); and (HD-10-003) to allow a new rear and side addition at 875 Ashland Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Audrey Godiers
1760 Marlbrook Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of January 27, 2010, due to the need for a variance.
Commission Voted: (HD-10-018) Approved (HD-10-003) Approved with revised conditions.
5. Other Business—
6. Adjournment
Proposed
AGENDA
January 27, 2010
1. Call to Order 4:10pm
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Review and Comment (RC-09-253) on a proposed new City of Atlanta park at 830 Willoughby Way (“Historic 4th Ward Park”) – Property is zoned I-2.
Applicant: Jeffrey A. Lowe
1000 Abernathy Road
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
b) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-10-001) to allow a new detached garage in the rear of the property at 27 Howell Street – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 2).
Applicant: Monica Woods
2814 Oxford Drive, Decatur
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
c) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-002) to allow the installation of new signage at 240 N. Highland Avenue – Property is zoned I-2/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Inman Park Physicians
240 Highland Avenue, Bldg. 3, Suite E
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
d) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-003) to allow a new rear and side addition at 875 Ashland Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Audrey Godiers
1760 Marlbrook Drive
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of February 10, 2010, due to the need for a variance.
e) Review and Comment (RC-10-004) on window alterations and other renovations at 23 Camden Road – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: Sean Cash
4510 Wieuca Road
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
f) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-10-006) to allow front façade renovations at 543 Atlanta Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District.
Applicant: Marie Mower
647 Glenwood Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
g) Review and Comment (RC-10-007) on the reconfiguration overflow parking for the Chastain Park Amphitheater at 4469 Stella Drive (Chastain Park Hilltop) – Property is zoned R-3.
Applicant: Shields Engineering Group, Inc.
409 John Wesley Dobbs
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support with comments.
h) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-122) to allow the demolition of a two-story building due to a threat to public health and safety at 227-229 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4).
Applicant: Ivan Thornton
304 Park Avenue South, New York, New York
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, due to the need for proper notice.
-Deferred from the meeting of August 12, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of February 24, 2010, at the Applicant's request.
i) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-139) to allow the demolition of a building due to unreasonable economic return at 245/247 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4).
Applicant: Quencis Jones
975 Tuckawanna Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of August 27, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of February 24, 2010, at the Applicant's request.
j) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (IP-09-201) to allow site work (community garden) in Freedom Park (intersection of Hurt and Euclid Avenues) – Property is zoned SPI-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Inman Park Community Garden
970 Waverly Way
-Deferred from the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of February 10, 2010.
k) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-221) for a variance from the requirement that the compatibility rule comparison be based on the subject property’s block, a variance from the requirement that the compatibility rule comparison be based on structures of like use, and a variance to allow an increase in the front yard setback from 0’ (required) to 5’ (proposed) and (LD-09-183) to allow lot consolidation and the construction of a new single family house at 605 – 609 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District.
Applicant: Jason Parker
10 Jackson Street
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of February 10, 2010, at the Applicant's request.
l) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness (HD-09-274) for a variance to allow a garage entrance on the front façade; and (HD-09-204) to allow an addition and other renovations at 654 Glenwood Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Stanley Sugarman
88 Bates Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Commissioner’s request.
Commission Voted: (HD-09-274) Approved (7-1). (HD-09-204) Approved with conditions (7-1).
m) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-264) to allow the demolition of a structure due to a threat to public health and safety and an Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-265) to allow a replacement structure at 1509 South Ponce de Leon Avenue – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Allen Post/ Perkins+Will
1382 Peachtree Street
-Deferred from the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Commissioner’s request.
Commission Voted: (LD-09-264) Approved with conditions.
(LD-09-265) Deferred until the meeting of February 24, 2010, at the Staff's request.
n) Review and Comment (RC-09-277) on the Ansley Park Traffic Improvement Revised Master Plan in the Ansley Park Neighborhood – Property is zoned R-3.
Applicant: Tunnell & Tunnell Landscape Architecture for the Ansley Park Civic Association
1123 Zondite Road, Suite1
-Deferred from the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of February 24, 2010, at the Commissioner's request.
5. Other Business—
6. Adjournment 8:09pm
Proposed
AGENDA
January 13, 2010
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (IP-09-201) to allow site work (community garden) in Freedom Park (intersection of Hurt and Euclid Avenues) – Property is zoned SPI-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Inman Park Community Garden
970 Waverly Way
-Deferred from the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission's Vote: Deferred until the meeting of January 27, 2010, at the Commissioner's request.
b) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness (HD-09-274) for a variance to allow a garage entrance on the front façade; and (HD-09-204) to allow an addition and other renovations at 654 Glenwood Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/ Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Stanley Sugarman
88 Bates Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission's Vote: Deferred until the meeting of January 27, 2010, at the Commissioner's request.
c) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-223) to allow window removal and replacement at 973 Beecher Street – Property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: Tom Klein
973 Beecher Street
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
Commission's Vote: Approved with conditions.
d) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-228) to allow an addition and renovations at 1251 Greenwich Street – Property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: Anna-Marie Muslar
6470 Long Island Drive, Sandy Springs
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
Commission's Vote: Deferred until the meeting of February 10, 2010, at the Commissioner's and Staff's request.
e) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness (LD-09-236) for a variance for a rear addition to be taller than the existing structure; and (LD-09-234) to allow addition and other renovations at 139 Savannah Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Jeanne B. Dufour
201 15th Street
-Deferred from the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
Commission's Vote: Denied without prejudice.
f) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-255) to allow a new business sign at 240 N. Highland Avenue – Property is zoned I-2/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Blanche Ettinger/ Inman Park Coffee
121 Mandalay Road, Gainesville
Commission's Vote: Approved with conditions.
g) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-257) to allow a permanent wood handicap ramp, sidewalk repairs and sign removal at 575 Boulevard SE – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Jeffrey Wilson
181 Pearl Street
Commission's Vote: Approved with conditions.
h) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-258) to rebuild a front porch and window replacement at 829 Cherokee Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Jason Fargo
1920 Linwood Avenue, East Point
Commission's Vote: Approved with conditions.
i) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-260) to allow the construction of a new single family residence and detached garage at 801 Lynwood Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1) / Beltline Overlay.
Applicant: Robert Gunnison, Stoney River Construction
P. O. Box 2507, Decatur
Commission's Vote: Approved with conditions.
j) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-261) to allow the construction of a new single family residence at 807 Lynwood Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1) / Beltline Overlay.
Applicant: Robert Gunnison, Stoney River Construction
P. O. Box 2507, Decatur
Commission's Vote: Deferred until the meeting of February 10, 2010, at the Commissioner's request.
k) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-262) to allow renovations to the front façade and front porch at 489 Broyles Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Jason Fargo
1920 Linwood Avenue, East Point
Commission's Vote: Approved with conditions.
l) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-264) to allow the demolition of a structure due to a threat to public health and safety and an Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-265) to allow a replacement structure at 1509 South Ponce de Leon Avenue – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District.
Applicant: Allen Post/ Perkins+Will
1382 Peachtree Street
Commission's Vote: Deferred until the meeting of January 27, 2010, at the Commissioner's request.
m) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-266) to allow the replacement of a fence at 866 Oakdale Road – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District.
Applicant: Paul and Jill Ferdinands
866 Oakdale Road
Commission's Vote: Approved with conditions.
n) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-267) to allow renovations and additions at 170 Savannah Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Melody and Joseph Trivisone
163 Powell Street
Commission's Vote: Approved with revised conditions.
o) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-268) to allow rear addition and renovations at 538 Holderness Street – Property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: Joel C. Ingraham
165 W. Wieuca Road, Suite 305
Commission's Vote: Approved with conditions.
p) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-269) to allow a dormer addition and other renovations at 1384 Fairview Road – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District (Subarea 2 – Fairview Road).
Applicant: Karen Soorikian
219 Fairfield Street, Decatur
Commission's Vote: Approved with conditions.
q) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-271) to allow the installation of an in-ground pool, hot tub, and retaining walls at 1972 Whittier Avenue – Property is zoned R-4A/Whittier Mill Historic District.
Applicant: Veronica Cooper
1972 Whittier Avenue
Commission's Vote: Approved with conditions.
r) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-272) for a variance to allow metal or non-asphalt shingles when asphalt shingles would otherwise be required and an Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-273) to allow revisions to plans at 182 Degress Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Frank Neely, Frank G. Neely Design Inc.
1447 Peachtree Street, Suite 844
Commission's Vote: Deferred until the meeting of February 10, 2010, at the Applicant's request.
s) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-276) to allow renovations at 567 Holderness Street – Property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: Avis Smith
559 Holderness Street
Commission's Vote: Approved with conditions.
t) Review and Comment (RC-09-253) on a proposed new City of Atlanta park at 830 Willoughby Way (“Historic 4th Ward Park”) – Property is zoned I-2.
Applicant: Jeffrey A. Lowe
1000 Abernathy Road
Commission's Vote: Send a letter of support.
u) Review and Comment (RC-09-259) on a rear addition and conversion of a deck to a porch at 26 Palisades Road – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: Matt Junger
1582 Walker Street, Smyrna
Commission's Vote: Send a letter of support.
v) Review and Comment (RC-09-270) on the Master Plan and renovations for Orme Park (Elkmont Drive, NE) – Property is zoned R-4.
Applicant: Jay Wansley
1201 Peachtree Street
Commission's Vote: Send a letter of support.
w) Review and Comment (RC-09-275) on the renovations, alterations, and site work at 129 Huntington Road – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Application: Joel Ingraham
165 W. Wieuca Road, Suite 305
Commission's Vote: Send a letter of support.
x) Review and Comment (RC-09-277) on the Ansley Park Traffic Improvement Revised Master Plan in the Ansley Park Neighborhood – Property is zoned R-3.
Applicant: Tunnell & Tunnell Landscape Architecture for the Ansley Park Civic Association
1123 Zondite Road, Suite 1
Commission's Vote: Deferred until the meeting of January 27, 2010, at the Applicant's request.
y) Review and Comment (RC-09-278) on the National Register of Historic Places nomination for First Methodist Episcopal Church, South located at 360 Peachtree Street – Property is zoned SPI-16 (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Dr. David Crass, Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer
Georgia Historic Preservation Division
254 Washington Street
Commission's Vote: Send a strong letter of support.
5. Other Business
- Adoption of New Rules of Procedure- Commission voted unanimously.
- Report of Nominating Committee / Election of New Chair and Vice Chair
Allyson McCarthy, Chair- Commission voted unanimously
Don Rooney, Vice Chair- Commission voted unanimously
6. Adjournment (8:45pm)
Proposed
AGENDA
December 9, 2009
1. Call to Order 4:05pm
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CR-09-061) to allow the re-location of an existing cemetery located at 431 Pharr Road – Property is zoned R-G3.
Applicant: Brandon Marshall
P. O. Box 925, Stone Mountain
-Deferred from the meeting of April 22, 2009.
-Deferred from the meeting of June 10, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of August12, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of September 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Denied (7-1).
b) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-122) to allow the demolition of a two-story building due to a threat to public health and safety at 227-229 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4).
Applicant: Ivan Thornton
304 Park Avenue South, New York, New York
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, due to the need for proper notice.
-Deferred from the meeting of August 12, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of January 27, 2010, at the Applicant's request.
c) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-139) to allow the demolition of a building due to unreasonable economic return at 245/247 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4).
Applicant: Quencis Jones
975 Tuckawanna Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of August 27, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of January 27, 2010, at the Applicant's request.
d) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-167) for a variance from the requirement that chain link fences are not allowed in the front yard at 210 Peters Street – Property is zoned C-5-C/Castleberry Hill Landmark District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Laurel Emery
210 Peters Street, Suite E
-Deferred from the meeting of September 9, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of September 23, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
e) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-179) for a variance to reduce the left side yard setback from +/- 1 foot (approved) to 4 inches (proposed) to reduce the front yard setback from 13 feet (approved) to 12 feet 9.6 inches (proposed) and right side yard setback from 6 feet (approved) to 5 feet 8.4 inches (proposed); and Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-181) for a revision to plans for a new house at 658 Narrow Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Shona Griffin
2160 Bagwell Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of September 23, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: HD-09-179 Approved with condition. HD-09-181 Approved with revised conditions.
f) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (IP-09-201) to allow site work (community garden) in Freedom Park (intersection of Hurt and Euclid Avenues) – Property is zoned SPI-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Inman Park Community Garden
970 Waverly Way
-Deferred from the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Applicant's request.
g) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-205) to allow the installation of a new fence in rear yard at 76 Howell Street – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 2).
Applicant: Cascade Fence Co. Inc.
1180 Fairburn Road
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, due to lack of sign posting affidavit.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, due to lack of sign posting affidavit.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
h) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-223) to allow window removal and replacement at 973 Beecher Street – Property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: Tom Klein
973 Beecher Strret
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of January 13, 2010, at the Staff's request.
i) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-228) to allow an addition and renovations at 1251 Greenwich Street – Property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: Anna-Marie Muslar
6470 Long Island Drive, Sandy Springs
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of January 13, 2010 due to lack of sign posting and Applicant's request.
j) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-231) to allow rear addition, renovations and site work at 839 Lake Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/ Inman Park Historic District.
Applicant: Adam Stillman
350 Sinclair Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
k) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness (LD-09-236) for a variance for a rear addition to be taller than the existing structure; and (LD-09-234) to allow addition and other renovations at 139 Savannah Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Jeanne B. Dufour
201 15th Street
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of January 13, 2010 at the Staff's request.
l) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-235) to allow a roofing change and roof related renovations at 1723 South Ponce de Leon Avenue – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: William Stephenson
1145 Alta Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
m) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-239) to allow new stairs and site work at 293 Georgia Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Gordon L. Warren, III
293 Georgia Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
n) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-240) to allow building renovations and site work at 1200 Ponce de Leon Avenue – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District.
Applicant: Barbara Crum/ Allen Post, Perkins & Will
1382 Peachtree Street
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
o) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-241) for a variance from the requirement to use asphalt shingles (required by the compatibility rule) to allow the installation of a standing seam metal roof (proposed) at 158 Elizabeth Street – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Robert Foah
158 Elizabeth Street
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of February 24, 2010, at the Applicant's request.
p) Review and Comment (RC-09-216) for temporary site work of ball fields at 500 Englewood Avenue (Boulevard Crossing Park) – Property is zoned Beltline Overlay District.
Applicant: Mathew Wilder, ASLA
834 Inman Village Parkway, Suite 100
-Deferred from the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support.
q) Review and Comment (RC-09-220) on a variance request (V-09-188) to reduce the west side yard setback from 7 feet (required) to 5 feet (proposed) and an addition and alterations at 102 Brighton Road – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: Brad Heppner
574 Hascall Road
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support.
r) Review and Comment (RC-09-226) on a standard tree well fencing design for the Midtown area of Atlanta (SPI-16 and SPI-17 Zoning Districts).
Applicant: Nathan Lawrence, Midtown Alliance
999 Peachtree Street NE, Suite 73
Commission Voted: Send letter of support.
s) Review and Comment (RC-09-233) on the revisions to plans at 213 Haygood Avenue (D. L. Stanton Park) – Property is zoned R-5-C.
Applicant: Kevin W. Burke, Atlanta Beltline Inc.
86 Pryor Street
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support.
t) Review and Comment (RC-09-237) on the demolition of an auxiliary building at 211 Memorial Drive (Cook Elementary) – Property is zoned RG-4.
Applicant: Atlanta Public Schools
1631 LaFrance Street
Commission Voted: Send a letter of comments; strongly opposition.
u) Review and Comment (RC-09-238) for driveway, parking and drainage improvements at 370 Old Ivy Road (Sarah Smith Elementary) – Property is zoned R-3.
Applicant: Atlanta Public Schools
1631 LaFrance Street
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support with comments.
5. Other Business: Rules of Procedure Revisions
6. Adjournment 9:26pm
Proposed
AGENDA
November 23, 2009
1. Call to Order 4:05pm
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CR-09-061) to allow the re-location of an existing cemetery located at 431 Pharr Road – Property is zoned R-G3.
Applicant: Brandon Marshall
P. O. Box 925, Stone Mountain
-Deferred from the meeting of April 22, 2009.
-Deferred from the meeting of June 10, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of August12, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of September 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
b) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-122) to allow the demolition of a two-story building due to a threat to public health and safety at 227-229 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4).
Applicant: Ivan Thornton
304 Park Avenue South, New York, New York
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, due to the need for proper notice.
-Deferred from the meeting of August 12, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
c) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-179) for a variance to reduce the left side yard setback from +/- 1 foot (approved) to 6 inches (proposed) for a new house and to reduce the front yard setback from 13 feet (approved) to 12 feet (proposed); and Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-181) for a revision to plans for a new house at 658 Narrow Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Shona Griffin
2160 Bagwell Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of September 23, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of November 23, 2009, due to the need for a revised variance request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of December 9, 2009, due to the need for a revised variance request.
d) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-221) for a variance from the requirement that the compatibility rule comparison be based on the subject property’s block, a variance from the requirement that the compatibility rule comparison be based on structures of like use, and a variance to allow an increase in the front yard setback from 0’ (required) to 5’ (proposed) and (LD-09-183) to allow lot consolidation and the construction of a new single family house at 605 – 609 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District.
Applicant: Jason Parker
10 Jackson Street
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of January 27, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
e) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-203) for the demolition of an existing porch and a rear addition at 724 Oakland Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Kelly Scibona
724 Oakland Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved.
f) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-204) to allow an addition and other renovations at 654 Glenwood Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/ Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Stanley Sugarman
88 Bates Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of January 13, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
g) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-205) to allow the installation of a new fence in rear yard at 76 Howell Street – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 2).
Applicant: Cascade Fence Co. Inc.
1180 Fairburn Road
-Deferred from the meeting of November 9, 2009, due to lack of sign posting affidavit.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of December 9, 2009, due to lack of sign posting affidavit.
h) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-214) to allow the removal and replacement of front porch at 846 Virgil Street – Property is zoned R-5/ Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: David Bock
5387 Redfield Road
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
i) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-218) to allow the construction of a second story addition and renovations at 947 Cherokee Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: John E. Swiney
145 Thistlewood Lane, Fairburn
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
j) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-219) to allow a new front addition and other renovations at 313 Boulevard, SE – Property is zoned C-2/ Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: John E. Swiney
145 Thistlewood Lane, Fairburn
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
k) Review and Comment (RC-09-193) for demolition of a 3 story accessory building at 627 English Avenue (English Avenue School) – Property is zoned R4-A.
Applicant: Atlanta Public Schools
130 Trinity Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
l) Review and Comment (RC-09-208) for a special use permit for a group home at 1041 Lawton Avenue – Property is zoned R-4A/Oakland City Historic District.
Applicant: Nathan Jideama
384 Lum Crowe Road, Roswell
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
m) Review and Comment (RC-09-213) on a text amendment to the Castleberry Hill Landmark District (Z-09-035) to create a definition of an off-leach dog park and to allow for such dog parks as a permitted use in Subarea 1.
Applicant: Referred by the Bureau of Planning
55 Trinity Avenue
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support.
n) Review and Comment (RC-09-215) on the installation of a history sign at 1500 McLendon Avenue (Candler Park).
Applicant: Maggie McBride
1383 Spring Street, Suite B
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support.
o) Review and Comment (RC-09-216) for temporary site work of ball fields at 500 Englewood Avenue (Boulevard Crossing Park) – Property is zoned Beltline Overlay District.
Applicant: Mathew Wilder, ASLA
834 Inman Village Parkway, Suite 100
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
5. Other Business:
6. Adjournment 7:44pm
Proposed
AGENDA
November 9, 2009
1. Call to Order 4:04pm
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CR-09-061) to allow the re-location of an existing cemetery located at 431 Pharr Road – Property is zoned R-G3.
Applicant: Brandon Marshall
P. O. Box 925, Stone Mountain
-Deferred from the meeting of April 22, 2009.
-Deferred from the meeting of June 10, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of August12, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of September 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
b) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-122) to allow the demolition of a two-story building due to a threat to public health and safety at 227-229 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4).
Applicant: Ivan Thornton
304 Park Avenue South, New York, New York
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, due to the need for proper notice.
-Deferred from the meeting of August 12, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
c) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-139) to allow the demolition of a building due to unreasonable economic return at 245/247 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4).
Applicant: Quencis Jones
975 Tuckawanna Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of August 27, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Commission's request.
d) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-155) to allow the demolition of an existing structure due to the threat to public health and safety at 256-258 Powell Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Timothy J. Wright
8642 Prather Drive, Jonesboro
-Deferred from the meeting of September 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of September 23, 2009.
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
e) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-194) for the installation of a rain garden and tree plantings at 742 Catherine Street (Adair Park I) – Property is zoned R-4A/Adair Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Fred Cartwright, DPRCA
675 Ponce de Leon Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of October 28, 2009, due to the need for proper sign posting.
Commission Voted: Approved.
f) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (IP-09-201) to allow site work (community garden) in Freedom Park (intersection of Hurt and Euclid Avenues) – Property is zoned SPI-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Inman Park Community Garden
970 Waverly Way
-Deferred from the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Commission's request.
g) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-203) for the demolition of an existing porch and a rear addition at 724 Oakland Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Kelly Scibona
724 Oakland Avenue
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Staff's request.
h) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-204) to allow an addition and other renovations at 654 Glenwood Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/ Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Stanley Sugarman
88 Bates Avenue
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Staff's request.
i) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-205) to allow the installation of a new fence in rear yard at 76 Howell Street – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 2).
Applicant: Cascade Fence Co. Inc.
1180 Fairburn Road
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of November 23, 2009, due to the lack of sign posting affadavit.
j) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-217) to allow re-roof at 1126 St. Charles Place – Property is zoned R-4/Atkins Park Historic District.
Applicant: Michael Williams
511 Trabert Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
k) Review and Comment (RC-09-206) on the design of food vending units for public right-of-way and property in the City of Atlanta.
Applicant: Atlanta Streatery, LLC
545 Glenmanor Court
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
5. Other Business: Approved deadline schedule for 2010.
6. Adjournment 7:07pm
Proposed
AGENDA
October 28, 2009
1. Call to Order 4:10pm
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-175) to allow rehabilitation of existing structure and the creation of off-street parking at 496-500 Old Wheat Street (aka 66-68 Hogue Street) – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 2).
Applicant: Pastor Thomas Thompson
64 Hogue Street
-Deferred from the meeting of September 23, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
b) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-179) for a variance to reduce the left side yard setback from +/- 1 foot (approved) to 6 inches (proposed) for a new house and to reduce the front yard setback from 13 feet (approved) to 12 feet (proposed); and Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-181) for a revision to plans for a new house at 658 Narrow Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Shona Griffin
2160 Bagwell Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of September 23, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
c) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-188) to allow rear addition and renovations at 179 Savannah Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Joe Griswell
227 Berean Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
d) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-194) for the installation of a rain garden and tree plantings at 742 Catherine Street (Adair Park I) – Property is zoned R-4A/Adair Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Fred Cartwright, DPRCA
675 Ponce de Leon Avenue
Commission Voted: Deferred, due to the need for proper sign posting.
e) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-196) to allow installation of new signage at 287 Elizabeth Street – Property is zoned C-1/Inman Park Historic District/ Beltline Overlay District.
Applicant: Meka Redd & Paul Nair
2270 Cammie Wages Road, Dacula
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
f) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LBS-09-199) to allow installation of new signage at 979 Crescent Avenue (Margaret Mitchell House) and 990 Peachtree Street/ 92 Peachtree Place (Commercial Row) – Property is zoned SPI-16/Landmark Building/Site (LBS).
Applicant: Jackson McQuigg
130 West Paces Ferry Road
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
g) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-200) to allow construction for the construction of a new accessory structure at 668 Gordon Place – Property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Karim Shahid
534 Medlock Road
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
h) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (IP-09-201) to allow site work (community garden) in Freedom Park (intersection of Hurt and Euclid Avenues) – Property is zoned SPI-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Inman Park Community Garden
970 Waverly Way
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of November 11, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
i) Review and Comment (RC-09-193) for demolition of a 3 story accessory building at 627 English Avenue (English Avenue School) – Property is zoned R4-A.
Applicant: Atlanta Public Schools
130 Trinity Avenue
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Commission's request.
j) Review and Comment (RC-09-195) for implementation of tree recompense plan (tree plantings) at Emma Millican Park, Avery Park, and Pittman Park.
Applicant: Fred Cartwright
675 Ponce de Leon Avenue
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
k) Review and Comment (RC-09-198) to review the master plan for a trail system and Phase II of that system at 308 Peachtree Hills Avenue (Peachtree Hills Park) – Property is zoned RG-2.
Applicant: Lynn F. Saussy & Pat Katz (DPRCA, City of Atlanta)
317 Glendale Avenue, Decatur
Commission Voted: Send a letter of strong support.
5. Other Business:
6. Adjournment 6:35pm
Proposed
AGENDA
October 14, 2009
1. Call to Order 4:15pm
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CR-09-061) to allow the re-location of an existing cemetery located at 431 Pharr Road – Property is zoned R-G3.
Applicant: Brandon Marshall
P. O. Box 925, Stone Mountain
-Deferred from the meeting of April 22, 2009.
-Deferred from the meeting of June 10, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of August12, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of September 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
b) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-122) to allow the demolition of a two-story building due to a threat to public health and safety at 227-229 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4).
Applicant: Ivan Thornton
304 Park Avenue South, New York, New York
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, due to the need for proper notice.
-Deferred from the meeting of August 12, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Commission's request.
c) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-139) to allow the demolition of a building due to unreasonable economic return at 245/247 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4).
Applicant: Quencis Jones
975 Tuckawanna Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of August 27, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Reconvene on the meeting of November 9, 2009.
d) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-155) to allow the demolition of an existing structure due to the threat to public health and safety at 256-258 Powell Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Timothy J. Wright
8642 Prather Drive, Jonesboro
-Deferred from the meeting of September 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of September 23, 2009.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of November 9, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
e) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-173) to allow demolition and a new addition to match the existing at 176 Powell Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Jason Snyder
176 Powell Street
-Deferred from the meeting of September 23, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with one condition.
f) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-178) to allow renovations, new dormer, new rear gable and single car garage at 220 Degress Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Frank Neely
220 Degress Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of September 23, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with one condition.
g) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-183) to allow lot consolidation and the construction of a new single family house at 605 – 609 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District.
Applicant: Jason Parker
10 Jackson Street
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of November 23, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
h) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-185) to allow landscape improvements at the Visitors Center located at 438 Memorial Drive – Property is zoned Oakland Cemetery Landmark District.
Applicant: Historic Oakland Foundation
248 Oakland Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved with comments.
i) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-188) to allow rear addition and renovations at 179 Savannah Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Joe Griswell
227 Berean Avenue
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Commission's request.
j) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-189) to allow window replacement at 146 Powell Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Judy Staples
217 Berean Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
k) Review and Comment (RC-09-180) for replacement of chainlink access gate and fence at 800 Cherokee Avenue (Zoo Atlanta) – Property is zoned R-5.
Applicant: Nevin Lash
366 Oakland Avenue
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support with comments.
l) Review and Comment (RC-09-182) on the master plan for the Morningside Nature Master Plan and suspension bridge at 1943 Wellbourne Road (Morningside Nature Preserve) – Property is zoned R-3.
Applicant: Pat Katz
675 Ponce de Leon
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support with comments.
m) Review and Comment (RC-09-186) for a special exception to erect a retaining wall exceeding the allowed height at 904 Cherokee Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/ Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Blake Spicer
904 Cherokee Avenue
Commission Voted: Send a letter of strong support.
n) Review and Comment (RC-09-190) for renovations and alterations to the Carnivore Complex at 800 Cherokee Avenue (Zoo Atlanta) – Property is zoned R-5.
Applicant: The Epstein Group
429 Edgewood Avenue
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support with comments.
o) Review and Comment (RC-09-191) for deck removal and other site alterations at 32 Huntington Road – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: David Bennett
2310 Clyde Drive
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support.
5. Other Business:
6. Adjournment 7:20pm
Proposed
AGENDA
September 23, 2009
1. Call to Order 4:05pm
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-120) to allow addition and renovations to an existing structure at 947 Cherokee Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Ronson Freeman
870 Mitchell Street
-Deferred from the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to lack of quorum.
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of August 26, 2009, at the Commissioners request.
Commission Voted: Denied without prejudice.
b) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-155) to allow the demolition of an existing structure due to the threat to public health and safety at 256-258 Powell Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Timothy J. Wright
8642 Prather Drive, Jonesboro
-Deferred from the meeting of September 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of October 14, 2009.
c) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-167) for a variance from the requirement that chain link fences are not allowed in the front yard at 210 Peters Street – Property is zoned C-5-C/Castleberry Hill Landmark District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Laurel Emery
210 Peters Street, Suite E
-Deferred from the meeting of September 9, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of December 9, 2009, at the Staff’s request.
d) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-172) to allow a new rear deck and stairs to an existing residence at 881 Springdale Road – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District.
Applicant: Karen Soorikian
219 Fairfield Street
Commission Voted: Approved.
e) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-173) to allow demolition and a new addition to match the existing at 176 Powell Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Jason Snyder
176 Powell Street
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
f) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-175) to allow rehabilitation of existing structure at 496 Old Wheat Street (aka 66 Hogue Street) – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 2).
Applicant: Pastor Thomas Thompson
64 Hogue Street
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
g) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-176) to allow addition of sign extensions to five existing park signs located along Ponce de Leon Avenue between Briarcliff Road and Atlanta City limits.
Applicant: Kirk Elifson
1410 Fairview Road
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
h) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-178) to allow renovations, new dormer, new rear gable and single car garage at 220 Degress Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Frank Neely
220 Degress Avenue
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
i) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-179) for a variance to reduce the left side yard setback from +/- 1 foot (approved) to 0 feet for a new house; and Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-183) for a revision to plans for a new house at 658 Narrow Street – Property is zoned R-5/ Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Shona Griffin
2160 Bagwell Drive
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of October 28, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
j) Review and Comment (RC-09-128) for the demolition of an existing single family house and the construction of a new single-family house at 84 Wakefield Drive – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: Anne-Michael Sustman, Summerour Architects
409 Bishop Street
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of August 12, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Denied without prejudice.
k) Review and Comment (RC-09-165) for the demolition of an existing single family residence at 84 Wakefield Drive – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: Greg Block
3400 Northside Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of September 9, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments of Staff and Commission, “strongly opposition”.
l) Review and Comment (RC-09-174) for site improvements at 213 Haygood Avenue (D. L. Stanton Park) – Property is zoned R-5-C.
Applicant: Paul Taylor
675 Ponce de Leon Avenue
Commission Voted: Send letter with comments.
m) Review and Comment (RC-09-177) to construct six new historic markers at 800 Cherokee Avenue (Zoo Atlanta) – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District.
Applicant: Grant Park Conservancy
499 Broyles Street
Commission Voted: Send letter with comments.
5. Other Business:
6. Adjournment 6:30pm
Proposed
AGENDA
September 9, 2009
1. Call to Order 4:05pm
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Nomination of the Imperial Hotel as a Landmark Building/Site (LBS) (N-09-157) at 355 Peachtree Center Avenue, NE – Property is zoned SPI-1(SA1)/HBS (Historic Building / Site).
Applicant: Progressive Imperial Ptnrs, LP/Progressive Redevelopment, Inc.
321 W. Hill Street, Decatur
Commission Voted: Approved.
b) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness CR-09-061) to allow the re-location of an existing cemetery located at 431 Pharr Road – Property is zoned R-G3.
Applicant: Brandon Marshall
P. O. Box 925, Stone Mountain
-Deferred from the meeting of April 22, 2009.
-Deferred from the meeting of June 10, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of August12, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
c) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-148) to allow a rear addition, front porch renovations and dormers at 842 Virgil Street – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Jody R. Hill
890 Arlington Place
-Deferred from the meeting of August 26, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
d) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-155) to allow the demolition of an existing structure due to the threat to public health and safety at 256-258 Powell Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Timothy J. Wright
8642 Prather Drive, Jonesboro
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of September 23, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
e) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness: (HD-09-158) for a variance to allow a garage door on a side façade that is visible from a public park or street; and (HD-09-159) to allow a rear addition at 1035 Austin Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/ Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Adam Stillman
350 Sinclair Avenue
Commission Voted: (HD-09-158) Approved. (HD-09-159) Approved with conditions.
f) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-160) for a variance to allow a stacked stone foundation at 373 Park Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Christopher Reilly
373 Park Avenue
Commission Voted: Denied without prejudice.
g) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-162) to allow a new deck and renovations at 428 Boulevard, SE – Property is zoned C-1/Grant Park Historic District.
Applicant: Joel Sadler
428 Boulevard, SE
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
h) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LBS-09-163) to allow replacement wall for trash area at 30 5th Street (The Biltmore House) – Property is zoned SPI-16 (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Ron Wright
30 5th Street, #206
Commission Voted: Approved.
i) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-164) to allow a new fence in front, side and rear yards at 564 Holderness Street – Property is zoned R-4A/ West End Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Westley Moore
564 Holderness Street
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
j) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-166) to allow new doors and other alterations and renovations at 300 N. Highland Avenue – Property is zoned I-2/Inman Park Historic District.
Applicant: Thomas Stevens
300 N. Highland Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
k) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-167) for a variance from the requirement that chain link fences are not allowed in the front yard at 210 Peters Street – Property is zoned C-5-C/Castleberry Hill Landmark District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Laurel Emery
210 Peters Street, Suite E
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of September 23, 2009, at the Staff's request.
l) Review and Comment (RC-09-165) for the demolition of an existing single family residence at 84 Wakefield Drive – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: Greg Block
3400 Northside Drive
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of September 23, 2009, at the Commission's request.
5. Other Business:
6. Adjournment 7:10pm
Proposed
AGENDA
August 26, 2009
1. Call to Order 4:05pm
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-120) to allow addition and renovations to an existing structure at 947 Cherokee Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Ronson Freeman
870 Mitchell Street
-Deferred from the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to lack of quorum.
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of September 23, 2009, at the Commissioner’s request.
b) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-136) to allow a rear addition to existing structure at 992 Oglethorpe Avenue – Property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: Michael Edey
980 Oglethorpe Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of August 12, 2009.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
c) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-140) to allow renovations and replacement doors at 491 Dargan Place – Property is zoned R-4A/ West End Historic District.
Applicant: Handy Andy Home Renovations
796 Pleasant Hill Road, Lilburn
-Deferred from the meeting of August 12, 2009.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
d) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-143) to allow door replacement and shutter addition at 725 Oakland Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/ Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Michael & Angela Laurie
725 Oakland Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of August 12, 2009.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
e) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-139) ) to allow the demolition of a building due to unreasonable economic return at 245/247 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4).
Applicant: Quencis Jones
975 Tuckawanna Drive
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
f) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-145) to allow a new rear addition and deck at 769 Dixie Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Craig J. Tindall
769 Dixie Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
g) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-146) to allow lot subdivisions and consolidations at 300 Peters Street – Property is zoned Castleberry Hill Landmark District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Fabric Developers, LLC
230 Forsyth Street
Commission Voted: Approved.
h) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-147) to allow renovations and additions to an existing building at 760 Confederate Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Jeffrey Wren
533 W. Howard Avenue, Studio A-2
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
i) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-148) to allow a rear addition, front porch renovations and dormers at 842 Virgil Street – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Jody R. Hill
890 Arlington Place
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of September 9, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
j) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-151) to allow window replacement at 736 Queen Street – Property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: BBI Group, LLC
913 Highbury Lane, Marietta
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
k) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-153) to allow installation of a fence at 427-429 Edgewood Avenue – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 5).
Applicant: Emily Mason/ Dagmar Epsten
429 Edgewood Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
l) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-154) to allow signage at 566-B Boulevard SE – Property is zoned Grant Park Historic District.
Applicant: Ryter Cannon
1093 Berne Street
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
m) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-156) to allow installation of a fence at 1368 Ponce de Leon Avenue – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District.
Applicant: Brandi Flanagan
1260 Fairview Road
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
n) Review and Comment (RC-09-152) on the installation of a retaining wall at 688 Grant Street (Neighborhood Charter School) – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District.
Applicant: Neighborhood Charter School
688 Grant Street
Commission Voted: Send a letter wit comments.
5. Other Business:
6. Adjournment 6:06pm
Proposed
AGENDA
August 12, 2009
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CR-09-061) to allow the re-location of an existing cemetery located at 431 Pharr Road – Property is zoned R-G3.
Applicant: Brandon Marshall
P. O. Box 925, Stone Mountain
-Deferred from the meeting of April 22, 2009.
-Deferred from the meeting of June 10, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of September 9, 2009, at the Commissioner's request.
b) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-117) to allow window replacement at 373 Park Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Virginia Chambers
2141 Kerr Road
-Deferred from the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to lack of quorum.
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, at the Commissioner’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
c) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-122) to allow the demolition of a two-story building due to a threat to public health and safety at 227-229 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4)
Applicant: Ivan Thornton
304 Park Avenue South, New York, New York
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, due to the need for proper notice.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of October 14, 2009, at the Commissioner's request.
d) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-125) to allow alterations, additions, and new garden shed at 273 and 279 Georgia Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1)
Applicant: Lance M. Carlson, AIA
1488 Pine Street, NW
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, due to the need for proper notice.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
e) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-130) to allow alterations and renovations to an existing single family house at 445 Robinson Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Nick Kharazmi
475 Lees Trace, Marietta
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, at the Commissioner’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
f) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-136) to allow a rear addition to existing structure at 992 Oglethorpe Avenue – Property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: Michael Edey
980 Oglethorpe Avenue
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of August 26, 2009.
g) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-137) to allow a rear addition and removal of non-historic addition and deck at 738 Boulevard SE – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Michael Dryden
398 Grant Park Place
Commission Voted: Approved.
h) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-138) to allow new signage at 240 N. Highland Avenue NE – Property is zoned I-1/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: In Focus Eye Center
240 N. Highland Avenue, Suite B
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
i) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-140) to allow renovations and replacement doors at 491 Dargan Place – Property is zoned R-4A/ West End Historic District.
Applicant: Handy Andy Home Renovations
796 Pleasant Hill Road, Lilburn
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of August 26, 2009.
j) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-142) to allow the removal of a door and installation of siding at 1977 Whittier Avenue – Property is zoned R-4A/Whittier Mill Historic District.
Applicant: Jason Jackoniski
1283 Briarcliff Road
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
k) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-143) to allow door replacement and shutter addition at 725 Oakland Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/ Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Michael & Angela Laurie
725 Oakland Avenue
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of August 26, 2009.
l) Review and Comment (RC-09-128) for the demolition of an existing single family house and the construction of a new single-family house at 84 Wakefield Drive – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: Anne-Michael Sustman, Summerour Architects
409 Bishop Street
-Deferred from the meeting of July 22, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of September 23, 2009, at the Commissioner's request.
m) Review and Comment (RC-09-135) on the changes to detention pond and grading at 3090 McMurray Drive (Kimberly Elementary School) – Property is zoned R-5.
Applicant: Atlanta Public Schools
1631 LaFrance Street
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
5. Other Business:
- Adoption of new application deadline schedule for the rest of 2009
Commission Voted: Unanimously in favor of.
6. Adjournment: 7:12pm.
PROPOSED
AGENDA
July 8, 2009
(Reconvened July 22, 2009)
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-100) to allow rooftop additions at 464 Edgewood Avenue – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 5).
Applicant: Kevin Holt
464 Edgewood Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of June 10, 2009, due to the need for a revised public notice.
-Deferred from the meeting of June 24, 2009 at the Staff’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to lack of quorum.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
b) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-101) for a variance to allow modified bitumen roofing to be installed on front porch at 817 Cherokee Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Brandy Morrison
637 Woodward Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of June 10, 2009, due to the need for a revised public notice.
-Deferred from the meeting of June 24, 2009 at the Applicants request.
-Deferred from the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to lack of quorum.
Commission Voted: Denied without prejudice.
c) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-108) to allow a rear addition to an existing dwelling at 640 Holderness Street – Property is zoned R-4A / West End Historic District.
Applicant: Kevin Houser
940 Hope Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of June 24, 2009 at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to lack of quorum.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
d) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness: (LD-09-121) for a variance to increase the right side yard setback from 0’ (required) to 12’11” (proposed); to reduce the rear yard setback from 12’ 2 ½” (required) to 9’2” (proposed); to increase the front yard setback from 3’8” (required) to 11’ (proposed); and (LD-09-109) to allow the construction of a convenience store at 400 Edgewood Avenue – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 5).
Applicant: Amin Panjwani
400 Edgewood Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of June 24, 2009 at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to lack of quorum.
Commission Voted: (LD-09-121) Approved with conditions. (LD-09-109) Approved with conditions.
e) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-117) to allow window replacement at 373 Park Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Virginia Chambers
2141 Kerr Road
-Deferred from the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to lack of quorum.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of August 12, 2009.
f) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-119) to allow additions and alterations to an existing structure at 940 Austin Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Ryan Taylor
481 Rebecca Lane, Smyrna
-Deferred from the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to lack of quorum.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
g) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-120) to allow addition and renovations to an existing structure at 947 Cherokee Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Ronson Freeman
870 Mitchell Street
-Deferred from the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to lack of quorum.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of August 26, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
PROPOSED
AGENDA
July 22, 2009
h) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-122) to allow the demolition of a two-story building due to a threat to public health and safety at 227-229 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4)
Applicant: Ivan Thornton
304 Park Avenue South, New York, New York
Commission Voted: Deferred to the meeting of August 12, 2009, due to the need for proper notice.
i) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-125) to allow alterations, additions, and new garden shed at 273 and 279 Georgia Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/ Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1)
Applicant: Lance M. Carlson, AIA
1488 Pine Street, NW
Commission Voted: Deferred to the meeting of August 12, 2009, due to the need for proper notice.
j) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-129) to allow replacement of windows at 829 Ashland Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: George Cameli
829 Ashland Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved with one conditon.
k) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-130) to allow alterations and renovations to an existing single family house at 445 Robinson Avenue – Property is zoned R-5 / Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Nick Kharazmi
475 Lees Trace, Marietta
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of August 12, 2009.
l) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-131) to allow new exterior stair at 1509 Ponce de Leon Avenue – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District (Ponce de Leon Corridor).
Applicant: Allen Post, Perkins and Will
1382 Peachtree Street
Commission Voted: Denied without prejudice.
m) Review and Comment (RC-09-127) for stream restoration work at 308 Peachtree Hills Avenue (Peachtree Hills Park) – Property is zoned RG-2.
Applicant: Pat Katz, Dept. of Parks, Recreation, and Cultural Affairs
675 Ponce de Leon Avenue, NE
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
n) Review and Comment (RC-09-128) for the demolition of an existing single family house and the construction of a new single-family house at 84 Wakefield Drive – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: Anne-Michael Sustman, Summerour Architects
409 Bishop Street
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of August 12, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
5. Other Business:
6. Adjournment: 6:50pm.
PROPOSED
AGENDA
June 24, 2009
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness (HD-09-091) for a variance to reduce the right side yard setback from 6’ (required) to 5’6” (proposed) for a new house and (HD-09-095) for a revision to plans for a new house at 656 Narrow Street - Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District.
Applicant: Scott Brown
1580 Commerce Drive, Decatur
- Deferred from the meeting of June 10, 2009, due to the need for a public notice.
Commission Voted: (HD-09-091) Approved. (HD-09-095) Approved with conditions.
b) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-100) to allow rooftop additions at 464 Edgewood Avenue – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 5).
Applicant: Kevin Holt
464 Edgewood Avenue
- Deferred from the meeting of June 10, 2009, due to the need for a public notice.
Commission Voted: Deferred to the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to the need for a revised public notice.
c) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-101) for a variance to allow modified bitumen roofing to be installed on front porch at 817 Cherokee Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Brandy Morrison
637 Woodward Avenue
- Deferred from the meeting of June 10, 2009, due to the need for a public notice.
Commission Voted: Deferred to the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to the need for a revised public notice.
d) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-098) to allow the construction of a new single family dwelling at 605 and 609 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned at Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 2).
Applicant: Jason Parker
10 Jackson Street, SE
Commission Voted: Denied without prejudice.
e) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-108) to allow a rear addition to an existing dwelling at 640 Holderness Street – Property is zoned R-4A / West End Historic District.
Applicant: Kevin Houser
940 Hope Drive
Commission Voted: Deferred to the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to the need for proper public notice.
f) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness: (LD-09-121) for a variance to increase the right side yard setback from 0’ (required) to 12’11” (proposed); to reduce the rear yard setback from 12’ 2 ½” (required) to 9’2” (proposed); to increase the front yard setback from 3’8” (required) to 11’ (proposed); and (LD-09-109) to allow the construction of a convenience store at 400 Edgewood Avenue – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 5).
Applicant: Amin Panjwani
400 Edgewood Avenue
Commission Voted: Deferred to the meeting of July 8, 2009, due to the need for proper public notice.
g) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-112) to allow window replacement at 20 Waddell Street – Property is zoned I-1/Inman Park Historic District.
Applicant: Cynthia Knapp
20 Waddell Street
Commission Voted: Approved.
h) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-114) to allow dormers, renovations and other alterations at 857 Oakdale Road – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District.
Applicant: M. Evan Lindsay
857 Oakdale Road
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
i) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-115) to allow signage at 300 North Highland Avenue – Property is zoned I-2/Inman Park Historic District.
Applicant: Thomas Stevens
P O Box 897
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
j) Review and Comment (RC-09-106) on the construction of a two-story, side addition at 80 Palisades Road – Property is zoned R-4/ Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: Joel Ingraham
165 W. Wieuca Road, NE #305
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments of the Staff and Commission.
k) Review and Comment (RC-09-110) on the installation of public art and rotating public art installation at 310 Peachtree Street (Hardy Ivy Park) – Property is zoned SPI-1.
Applicant: City of Atlanta
Office of Cultural Affairs
675 Ponce de Leon Avenue
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments of the Staff and Commission.
l) Review and Comment (RC-09-111) on the removal of rear porch, new rear addition and other renovations to an existing dwelling at 52 Wakefield Drive – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: Ben and Michele Garren
52 Wakefield Drive
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
5. Other Business
6. Adjournment: 6:50
PROPOSED
AGENDA
June 10, 2009
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
AGENDA
May 27, 2009
(Reconvened June 10, 2009)
3:00 pm
a) Review and Comment (RC-09-060) on the demolition of a structure at 433 Peeples Street (Dean Rusk Building) – Property is zoned R-G3.
Applicant: Shona Griffin
400 Park Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of April 8, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of May 13, 2009 at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Send letter with comments; strongly against demolition.
b) Review and Comment (RC-09-080) on alterations at 137 Brighton Road – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: Chrystal Butts
1991 Rockledge Road
- Deferred from the meeting of May 13, 2009 at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
c) Review and Comment (RC-09-094) on a permanent structure at 91 Peachtree Street (Woodruff Park) - Property is zoned SPI-1 (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Atlanta Downtown Improvement District
50 Hurt Plaza, Suite 110
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
d) Review and Comment (RC-09-096) on the National Register of Historic Places nomination for the Cecil and Hermione Alexander House at 2322 Mt. Paran Road, N.W. – Property is zoned R-2.
At the request of: Ray Luce
Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer
Georgia State Historic Preservation Office
Commission Voted: Send a letter of stronf support.
AGENDA
May 27, 2009
(Reconvened June 10, 2009)
4:00 pm
e) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-040) to allow the demolition of a single family residence due to the threat to public health and safety at 489 Culberson Street – Property is zoned at R-4A/ West End Historic District.
Applicant: City of Atlanta- In Rem
55 Trinity Avenue, Suite 3450
- Deferred from the meeting of March 25, 2009, at the Commissioner’s request.
- Deferred from the meeting of April 22, 2009.
- Deferred from the meeting of May 13, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Deny
f) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CR-09-061) to allow the re-location of an existing cemetery located at 431 Pharr Road – Property is zoned R-G3.
Applicant: Brandon Marshall
P. O. Box 925, Stone Mountain
- Deferred from the meeting of April 22, 2009.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of August 12, 2009, at the Commission's request.
g) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-078) to allow front porch renovations at 695 Rosalia Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Niall Rochford
2306 Dennington Court, Smyrna
- Deferred from the meeting of May 13, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
h) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-083) to allow renovations, new storefronts, new windows and signage at 180 and 186 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District.
Applicant: John Swiney
145 Thistlewood Lane
-Deferred from the meeting of May 13, 2009 at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
i) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-091) for a variance to reduce the right side yard setback from 6’ (required) to 5’6” (proposed) for a new house and (HD-09-095) for a revision to plans for a new house at 656 Narrow Street- Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District.
Applicant: Scott Brown
1580 Commerce Drive, Decatur
Commission Voted: Deferred to the meeting of June 24, 2009, due to the need for proper public notice.
[Deferred items will not be separately listed on the June 10th agenda].
PROPOSED
AGENDA
June 10, 2009
a) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-100) to allow rooftop additions at 464 Edgewood Avenue – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 5).
Applicant: Kevin Holt
464 Edgewood Avenue
Commission Voted: Deferred to the meeting of June 24, 2009, due to the need for proper public notice.
b) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-101) for a variance to allow modified bitumen roofing to be installed on front porch at 817 Cherokee Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Brandy Morrison
637 Woodward Avenue
Commission Voted: Deferred to the meeting of June 24, 2009, due to the need for proper public notice.
c) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-102) to allow the installation of a privacy fence at 71 Boulevard, NE – Property is zoned Martin L. King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 2).
Applicant: Wayne Brawner
71 Boulevard, NE
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
d) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-104) to allow renovations, additions, and accessory structure at 182 Degress Avenue– Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District.
Applicant: Frank Neely
1447 Peachtree Street, Suite #844
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
e) Review and Comment (RC-09-099) on the construction of a dog park at 1955 Compton Drive (South Bend Park) – Property is zoned R-4.
Applicant: Park Pride
675 Ponce de Leon Avenue
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments and observations.
f) Review and Comment (RC-09-103) on renovations and additions to Therrell High School at 3099 Panther Trail- Property is zoned R-4.
Applicant: M. Susanne Blam
1382 Peachtree Street, NE
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
g) Review and Comment (RC-09-105) on renovations and additions to Fickett Elementary School at 3935 Rux Road- Property is zoned R-4.
Applicant: Christopher Tidwell
409 John Wesley Dobbs
Commission Voted: Send a letter with Staff Report and comments.
5. Other Business
6. Adjournment: 6:37pm
PROPOSED
AGENDA
May 27, 2009
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-040) to allow the demolition of a single family residence due to the threat to public health and safety at 489 Culberson Street – Property is zoned at R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: City of Atlanta- In Rem
55 Trinity Avenue, Suite 3450
- Deferred from the meeting of March 25, 2009, at the Commissioner’s request.
- Deferred from the meeting of April 22, 2009.
- Deferred from the meeting of May 13, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
NO QUORUM
b) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CR-09-061) to allow the re-location of an existing cemetery located at 431 Pharr Road – Property is zoned R-G3.
Applicant: Brandon Marshall
P. O. Box 925, Stone Mountain
- Deferred from the meeting of April 22, 2009.
NO QUORUM
c) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-078) to allow front porch renovations at 695 Rosalia Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Niall Rochford
2306 Dennington Court, Smyrna
- Deferred from the meeting of May 13, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
NO QUORUM
d) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-083) to allow renovations, new storefronts, new windows and signage at 180 and 186 Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King Jr, Landmark District.
Applicant: John Swiney
145 Thistlewood Lane
- Deferred from the meeting of May 13, 2009 at the Commission’s request.
NO QUORUM
e) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-091) for a variance to reduce the right side yard setback from 6’ (required) to 5’7” (proposed) for a new house and (HD-09-095) for a revision to plans for a new house at 656 Narrow Street- Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District
Applicant: Scott Brown
1580 Commerce Drive, Decatur
NO QUORUM
f) Review and Comment (RC-09-060) on the demolition of a structure at 433 Peeples Street (Dean Rusk Building) – Property is zoned R-G3
Applicant: Shona Griffin
400 Park Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of April 8, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
-Deferred from the meeting of May 13, 2009 at the Applicant’s request.
NO QUORUM
g) Review and Comment (RC-09-080) on alterations at 137 Brighton Road – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: Chrystal Butts
1991 Rockledge Road
- Deferred from the meeting of May 13, 2009 at the Applicant’s request.
NO QUORUM
h) Review and Comment (RC-09-094) on a permanent structure at 91 Peachtree Street (Woodruff Park) - Property is zoned SPI-1 (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Atlanta Downtown Improvement District
50 Hurt Plaza, Suite 110
NO QUORUM
i) Review and Comment (RC-09-096) on the National Register of Historic Places nomination for the Cecil and Hermione Alexander House at 2232 Mt. Paran Road, N.W. – Property is zoned R-2.
At the request of: Ray Luce
Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer
Georgia State Historic Preservation Office
NO QUORUM
5. Other Business
6. Adjournment
PROPOSED
AGENDA
May 13, 2009
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of Minutes
4. Business:
a) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-08-397) to allow renovations and an addition at 328-336 Ormond Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Brandy Morrison
637 Woodward Avenue
- Deferred from the meeting of December 10, 2008, at the Staff request.
- Deferred from the meeting of January 14, 2009, at the Applicants request.
- Deferred from the meeting of February 11, 2009, at the Applicant request.
- Deferred from the meeting of March 11, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
- Deferred from the meeting of March 25, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
- Deferred from the meeting of April 8, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
- Deferred from the meeting of April 22, 2009 at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
b) Application for a Type IV Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-040) to allow the demolition of a single family residence due to the threat to public health and safety at 489 Culberson Street – Property is zoned at R-4A/ West End Historic District.
Applicant: City of Atlanta- In Rem
55 Trinity Avenue, Suite 3450
- Deferred from the meeting of March 25, 2009, at the Commissioner’s request.
- Deferred from the meeting of April 22, 2009.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of May 27, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
c) Applications for Type III Certificates of Appropriateness (HD-09-053) for a variance to reduce the rear yard setback from 12’ (required) to 4” (proposed) for a carport at 257 Elizabeth Street – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Stephen Currie & Teresa Burk
257 Elizabeth Street
-Deferred from the meeting of April 8, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Approved.
d) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-056) to allow alterations and dormer addition at 115 Estoria Street – Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3).
Applicant: Daniel H. Blankenship
115 Estoria Street
Deferred from the meeting of April 8, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Denied without prejudice.
e) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-075) to allow the replacement of dormers at 731 Lawton Street- property is zoned R-4A/West End Historic District.
Applicant: Calvin Rambert
186 Torrence Street
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
f) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-076) to allow a rear porch enclosure at 1368 Ponce de Leon Avenue – Property is zoned Druid Hills Landmark District.
Applicant: Jim Jackson
1368 Ponce de Leon Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved.
g) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-077) to allow new construction of a single family residence at 342 Atlanta Avenue – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Brandy Morrison
637 Woodward Avenue
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
h) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-078) to allow front porch renovations at 695 Rosalia Street – Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Niall Rochford
2306 Dennington Court, Smyrna
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of May 27, 2009, at the Commissioner's request.
i) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-079) to allow renovations and rear addition at 845 Virgil Street – Property is zoned R-5/Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Shelley Bertsch & Craig Geiger
73 Spruce Street
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
j) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LD-09-083) to allow a new storefront and signage at 186-A Auburn Avenue – Property is zoned Martin Luther King Jr, Landmark District.
Applicant: John Swiney
145 Thistlewood Lane
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of May 27, 2009, at the Commissioner's request.
k) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-086) to allow alterations to an existing single family home at 675 Grady Place – Property is zoned R-4A / West End Historic District.
Applicant: Bobby Hilliard
6255 Campbellton Road
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
l) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HHD-09-087) to allow renovations to an existing single family house at 817 Cherokee Avenue - Property is zoned R-5/ Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Brandy Morrison
637 Woodward Avenue, SE
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
m) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (HD-09-088) to allow for a revision to plans at 1083 Austin Avenue - Property is zoned R-5 / Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Randy Pimsler
1383 Spring Street
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
n) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (LBS-09-089) to allow for new signage at 817 West Peachtree Street - Property is zoned SPI-16 (Subarea 1) / Biltmore Hotel Landmark Building / Site (LBS).
Applicant: Cary Greenleaf
817 West Peachtree Street
Commission Voted: Approved with conditions.
o) Review and Comment (RC-09-046) on new construction of reptile exhibits for the Atlanta Zoo at 800 Cherokee Avenue- Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Atlanta Fulton County Zoo, Inc.
800 Cherokee Avenue
-Deferred from the meeting of April 8, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
p) Review and Comment (RC-09-047) on new construction of an animal care complex for the Atlanta Zoo at 800 Cherokee Avenue- Property is zoned R-5/Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1).
Applicant: Atlanta Fulton County Zoo, Inc.
800 Cherokee Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of April 8, 2009, at the Applicant’s request.
Commission Voted: Send a letter of support with comments.
q) Review and Comment (RC-09-060) on the demolition of a structure at 433 Peeples Street (Dean Rusk Building) – Property is zoned R-G3
Applicant: Shona Griffin
400 Park Drive
-Deferred from the meeting of April 8, 2009, at the Commission’s request.
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of May 27, 2009, at the Applicant's request.
r) Review and Comment (RC-09-073) on general improvements to Piedmont Park at 400 Park Drive – Property is zoned R-4.
Applicant: Piedmont Park Conservancy
400 Park Drive
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
s) Review and Comment (RC-09-080) on alterations at 137 Brighton Road – Property is zoned R-4/Brookwood Hills Conservation District.
Applicant: Chrystal Butts
1991 Rockledge Road
Commission Voted: Deferred until the meeting of May 27, 2009, at the Commissioner's request.
t) Review and Comment (RC-09-084) on renovations to Grady High School Stadium at 929 Charles Allen Drive – Property is zoned R-5.
Applicant: Atlanta Public Schools
130 Trinity Avenue, SW
Commission Voted: Send a letter with comments.
u) Review and Comment (RC-09-085) on renovations to Lakewood Stadium at 70 Claire Drive, SW – Property is zoned R-4/I-1-C.
Applicant: Atlanta Public Schools
130 Trinity Avenue, SW
Commission Voted: Send a letter with Comments.
5. Other Business
6. Adjournment: 8:15pm
Official Website for the City of Atlanta • © • Disclaimer • Privacy Policy
|